Hundreds of injuries as restraint use soars, and a disabled patient treated ‘like a dog’. What’s going on at Carstairs hospital?

We investigated conditions at The State Hospital, which houses some of Scotland’s most serious criminal offenders. Our findings were described as "deeply concerning" and prompted calls for urgent action to improve patient care.

Hundreds of injuries as restraint use soars, and a disabled patient treated ‘like a dog’. What’s going on at Carstairs hospital?
Photo by Scarbor Siu / Unsplash

A sharp rise in the use of restraints at The State Hospital, Carstairs, resulted in more than 200 patient injuries, The Ferret can reveal, and at least two staff are under investigation after allegedly humiliating a disabled patient by treating them like a dog. 

Our investigation into conditions at Scotland’s high-security psychiatric site also found that patients were held in continuous seclusion for up to 24 days and self-harm more than tripled between 2022 and 2024, according to data we obtained. 

At least two qualified nurses are under investigation for the ‘dog incident’ when staff allegedly threw food on the floor for a patient to eat. Insiders claimed the episode lasted for over half an hour and involved “a game of fetch”.

Morale at the hospital is at an “all time low” due to staff shortages and workers have lost faith in senior management, sources claimed. The Ferret obtained the figures through a series of freedom of information requests, while sources who requested anonymity spoke to us about the alleged treatment of patients at the hospital. 

Commenting on our findings the Mental Welfare Commission said it has consistently raised concerns with the hospital and that “urgent action” is required to improve patient care. The Scottish Greens said the allegation that a patient was humiliated by staff is “appalling” and there were “serious questions” about the current situation at the facility. 

The use of physical restraint should be a “last resort”, said the Scottish Government, which added that it is “actively engaging” with the hospital over issues.

The State Hospital said “the safety, dignity and wellbeing of patients and staff” are paramount and that it was committed to improving patient care. A spokesperson added that it could not comment on confidential patient information or individual cases.

CTA Image

Help us report on difficult stories

For many years The Ferret has reported on stories that are not easy to tell. With the help of our members, we've investigated the sharpest end of the mental health crisis, deaths in prison and the shocking conditions of homeless accommodation as well as on those who profit.

We are committed to shining a spotlight on injustice and we won't look away. But stories like these take time and can be challenging.

Will you help us do more of this type of work for just £1 a week?

I want to support you

‘Boiling pot’ atmosphere on wards


Situated in South Lanarkshire’s exposed moorlands, The State Hospital –known as Carstairs – is surrounded by high fences and monitored by a 24/7 CCTV control room. The facility houses some of Scotland’s most serious criminal offenders, with a capacity of 144 beds. According to its most recent internal report, the majority of patients have a primary diagnosis of schizophrenia.

The Ferret understands that the incident involving the humiliation of a disabled patient happened in the summer and sources claimed it seriously affected morale. In a meeting on 6 July, staff were told that Police Scotland was notified of a “serious incident” in the disabilities ward. 

The incident, sources claimed, followed months of staff shortages which led to a rise in the restraint of  patients and left many in regular daytime confinement. The Ferret has seen emails confirming that a "serious incident" was discussed with a group of staff at the Intellectual Disabilities ward.

Police Scotland and the Mental Welfare Commission were notified. A Police Scotland spokesperson confirmed that “enquiries were carried out and no criminality has been established."

Ongoing concerns

The situation at Carstairs has prompted warnings from the Commission stretching back to 2021. It says patients have been confined to their rooms during the day as a result of understaffing and operational pressures, rather than any clinical need. A sustained period of routine daytime confinements prompted an unannounced visit in July from the Commission which found “no progress” had been made on the issue, despite its previous concerns.

Separately, our freedom of information requests found some patients have been held in a more severe form of isolation, known as continuous seclusion, for up to 24 days. Unlike daytime confinement, the hospital uses this type of confinement  for patients judged to pose an immediate risk to others, holding them in a  separate seclusion room. 

The Commission’s guidance says seclusion should be a final resort, last no longer than necessary and be reviewed regularly, with external review if it continues beyond 72 hours. 

The State Hospital told The Ferret that the term “solitary confinement” does “not reflect the terminology or clinical practices used at the State Hospital”.

Families are being left without support after a suicide – and it’s causing more deaths
Those bereaved by suicide have a 65 per cent increased risk of taking their own lives. So why is there not more funding for support after tragedy strikes?

According to the Commission, its July visit was further triggered by the hospital’s failure to alert it to a “significant incident”. The inspection led to an urgent directive published on 28 October calling for immediate action to “reduce and eliminate routine daytime confinement”.

Insiders claim that shortfalls of 10 to 30 staff per shift have been common in the last year, leaving nurses feeling increasingly exposed. While 700 staff are employed at the hospital, sources said that a minimum of four staff are required in each of the hospital's 12 wards per shift. Publicly available information confirms there have been staffing issues.

One source said the hospital had developed a reputation among NHS staff for “a general lack of trust”, “empty promises”, and “a culture of bullying and harassment” in some departments. Senior managers were described as out of touch with a “boiling pot” atmosphere on the wards, leaving frontline workers to absorb the fallout. 

Fuel our next investigation

This story was funded by people who want journalism that uncovers new things, challenges power, and serves the public. Help make the next one possible.

Become a member

The Ferret was told that on 24 April a psychiatric patient broke away from staff in their ward, shattering security glass, breaking through doors, and causing structural damage to the building.

Staff were forced into a retreat, escorting the rest of the ward’s patients to a separate secure area. Sources said the affected ward was “completely destroyed” and closed for months due to the extent of repairs. Left alone, the patient escaped from the ward and roamed the hospital’s outer grounds, they added.

An insider said it “was a miracle” no staff members or other patients were killed or dealt life-threatening injuries. Social media posts reported a police helicopter hovering over the hospital at the time.

Just weeks earlier, management had rolled out a new “integrated incident, risk management, and patient safety” system.

A Police Scotland spokesperson confirmed it attended an incident on 24 April and that a man was charged in connection with alleged vandalism and reported to the procurator fiscal.

Rise in restraint of mental health patients causes concern
Scotland’s Mental Welfare Commission is to examine the use of physical restraint in NHS facilities after data gathered by The Ferret revealed a rise in recorded incidents by health boards. Data released under a freedom of information request showed that six health boards across Scotland recorded a rise in

Surging use of restraints and rising patient injuries


The increased use of restraints at the hospital has also resulted in more than 200 patient injuries, including serious injuries and fractures, over the last five years, our freedom of information request revealed. 

The data we obtained breaks down the 3,079 uses of restraint since 2021 by different methods. Physical restraints more than tripled over the period, with 519 incidents recorded last year, while the use of belts and cuffs (mechanical restraints) rose from one case in 2023 to 97 in 2025. 

Prone restraints, where a patient is held face-down to the floor by at least two staff members, rose from 15 incidents in 2022 to 80 by the end of September 2026.

This method has been a source of controversy for years, however, and linked to the deaths of people with mental health problems. In 2014 mental health units in England were told to phase it out in response to concerns it “can result in dangerous compression of the chest and airways.”

At least one episode of continuous prone restraint at Carstairs lasted for over an hour, though the hospital’s records do not specify the total duration. 

Self-harm at the hospital more than tripled between 2022 and 2024, the figures show. 

Concerns were also raised about self-harm in the new women’s ward, where there have been over 150 incidents since July 2025, despite it typically holding less than its six-person maximum capacity.

Female patients were subject to more than double the amount of chemical and mechanical restraints compared to their male counterparts over the same period, despite there being over twenty times the number of men at the facility.

The women have been collectively subject to over 900 separate episodes of restraint since last August. 

Claims of a “failure of care”


The Mental Welfare Commission told The Ferret that "urgent action” is required by the hospital in response to its report and it expects the “board of the State Hospital to own and address this”. A spokesperson added: “Our report highlights the obvious risks to those who have a right to care and treatment, including increased restriction of liberty, institutionalisation, deterioration in mental state and functioning, reduced rehabilitation and prolonged admission.”

“We learned about the impact on staff too and that they did not always have confidence that they would be listened to or that action would be taken by those in senior positions.”

Professor Thanos Karatzias, an expert in mental health at Edinburgh Napier University, said: “From a trauma-informed perspective, these findings are deeply concerning. As such experiences risk exacerbating existing psychological distress, reinforcing previous trauma and ultimately contributing to poorer mental health outcomes.”

He claimed that patients in secure psychiatric facilities are “among the most vulnerable people receiving mental health care” adding, ”many have experienced significant trauma throughout their lives, and restrictive interventions such as physical restraint, forced medication and prolonged seclusion can recreate feelings of fear, helplessness and loss of control”.

"Patients and their families deserve to know why restraint has been used so frequently and what is being done to keep people safe." Scottish Greens

The Scottish Greens’ health spokesperson, Kayleigh Kinross-O’Neill MSP, said people being locked in rooms due to staff shortages is a “failure of care” and that the allegation a patient with a learning disability was “mocked and humiliated by staff is appalling”.

“This incident must be investigated fully and staff who raise concerns must be able to do so without fear of repercussions,” she added. “The rise in restraint and the levels of self-harm raises serious questions about the care patients are receiving. The figures from the women’s ward are particularly alarming. Patients and their families deserve to know why restraint has been used so frequently and what is being done to keep people safe.”

A Scottish Government spokesperson stressed that patient safety is “paramount” and while ministers cannot comment on individual cases adding, “everyone should be able to feel safe whilst receiving treatment or working in our mental health services, and the use of physical restraint should only ever be a last resort”.

They said the government expects The State Hospital to “take appropriate steps to ensure high quality, safe, and appropriate healthcare and is actively engaging with the board to address issues raised by the Mental Welfare Commission”.

A spokesperson for The State Hospital said: “The safety, dignity and wellbeing of patients and staff are central to the work of the State Hospital. We take concerns about patient care, staff conduct and working conditions seriously, and appropriate action is taken where concerns are substantiated.

“We acknowledge and welcome the recommendation made by the Mental Welfare Commission. We are committed to reducing and eliminating routine daytime confinement and have been working intensively to achieve this. Work is well underway, with a continued focus on improving patients’ experience. We cannot comment on confidential patient information or individual employment matters."

We’re committed to journalism with impact

Good reporting does more than fill the feed. Your support helps us make journalism that exposes wrongdoing and brings change.

Become a member

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to The Ferret.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.